header
header

Mahloket Matters at the Holiday Table

How can good people hold diametrically opposing views on moral issues? 

This essential question of Mahloket Matters can feel especially urgent when those people are sitting across your holiday table. As you gather this holiday season, you may bring strong feelings about the future, wherever you live. You may also wonder how your family and friends can understand the world so differently.

If you participated in the Mahloket Matters Fellowship, you may remember the story below. This season offers an opportunity to return to it and consider what it asks of you now.

Excerpt from Tractate Moed Katan 16b


Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi decreed that students not be taught in the marketplace… “Just as a thigh is hidden, so too the words of Torah.” …Rabbi Ḥiyya went out and taught his two nephews in the marketplace… Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi heard and became angry… Rabbi Ḥiyya conducted himself as if admonished for thirty days. …[When they met again, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi asked:] “Why did you, Master, act this way?” He answered: “For it is written: ‘Wisdom cries aloud in the streets’” (Proverbs 1:20). …Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi said to him: “If you read it, you did not study it; if you studied it, you did not review it a third time; if you reviewed it a third time, it was not explained to you”… “Whoever studies Torah inside, their Torah proclaims them outside.” 
גָּזַר רַבִּי שֶׁלֹּא יִשְׁנוּ לַתַּלְמִידִים בַּשּׁוּק… מָה יָרֵךְ בַּסֵּתֶר, אַף דִּבְרֵי תוֹרָה בַּסֵּתֶר.
יָצָא רַבִּי חִיָּיא וְשָׁנָה לִשְׁנֵי בְּנֵי אֶחָיו בַּשּׁוּק… שְׁמַע רַבִּי, אִיקְּפַד… נְהַג נְזִיפוּתָא בְּנַפְשֵׁיהּ תְּלָתִין יוֹמִין.
מַאי טַעְמָא עֲבַד מָר הָכִי? אֲמַר לֵיהּ, דִּכְתִיב: ״חׇכְמוֹת בַּחוּץ תָּרוֹנָּה״.
אֲמַר לֵיהּ: אִם קָרִיתָ, לֹא שָׁנִיתָ, וְאִם שָׁנִיתָ, לֹא שִׁילַּשְׁתָּ, וְאִם שִׁילַּשְׁתָּ, לֹא פֵּירְשׁוּ לְךָ… כׇּל הָעוֹסֵק בַּתּוֹרָה מִבִּפְנִים, תּוֹרָתוֹ מַכְרֶזֶת עָלָיו מִבַּחוּץ.

Cultivate intellectual curiosity

Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, also known as Rebbe, asks Rabbi Ḥiyya: Why did you act this way? Note that by the time he asks this question, anger has already created a month of distance. Rebbe’s question opens the possibility of understanding, but his response quickly closes it. You have not studied enough. You have not understood. 

You may recognize the pattern: asking someone to explain, then listening only long enough to tell them why they are wrong.

What might you discover if you stayed curious a little longer?

Value tensions and moral foundations

One way to read the conflict between Rebbe and Rabbi Ḥiyya is as a tension between sanctity and accessibility. Rebbe may fear that teaching Torah in the marketplace compromises the reverence and care it deserves. Rabbi Ḥiyya may fear that keeping Torah within designated spaces puts its wisdom beyond the reach of the people who need it most. Both are committed to Torah’s future. They differ over what most threatens that future and how best to protect it.

When you consider what each person fears losing, the disagreement becomes easier to understand. You can begin to recognize something precious beneath a position you might otherwise dismiss.

At your own table, you may hear positions first: whom someone voted for, which policy they support, what they believe should happen next. The values and fears beneath those positions take more work to uncover. You may both care deeply about security, fairness, loyalty, freedom, or care, yet reach very different conclusions about what those values demand.

Let’s get practical

How can we apply the above insights to take potential situations of conflict around your holiday table and shift them in a constructive direction?

Advance prep

Before gathering, begin with yourself and ask: “Which issues are likely to activate me? What value or need feels threatened? Am I ready to listen with the goal of understanding, without needing to convince or win?” 

In the moment

If a difficult conversation arises, try asking: “What are you most hoping to protect?” or “What worries you most about the alternative?” 

After they answer, check your understanding. Reflect, then ask: “Have I understood what matters most to you?”

Remember: understanding someone’s underlying values does not settle whether their position is right, or whether its consequences are acceptable. It gives you a fuller picture of the person with whom you disagree, and a better starting point for responding.

Dedication to transformation

Hanukkah means “dedication.” As you consider what deserves your dedication this season, you might begin with the practice of asking a question whose answer you are willing to hear. Around the candles and across the table, you have opportunities to practice.

May this season move us toward conflict transformation, deepening our relationships even where differences endure.

Jessica Minnen

Rabbi Jessica Minnen brings her passion for transformative Jewish learning to her position as Director of Faculty for Pardes North America. Originally from Kentucky, Jessica studied at Washington University in St. Louis, Pardes, Paideia: The European Institute for Jewish Studies in Sweden and Baltimore Hebrew University, and received rabbinic ordination from the Jewish Theological Seminary in 2013.

Jessica has taught widely for Jewish educational organizations including Hillel International, Birthright Israel and the Foundation for Jewish Camp. She was part of the founding team of OneTable, where she served as Rabbi in Residence, and now works with Momentum developing immersive learning experiences for women around the world. Jessica lives in Denver, Colorado and is mom to one amazing dog and one amazing human.